To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE


SHARE THIS ARTICLE Printer friendly version of this page

Huge Win: Judge Says Teachers Don't Have to Follow State's Gender Identity Secrecy Policy

California Family Council Staff : Sep 20, 2023  California Family Council

"Parental involvement [is] essential to the healthy maturation of schoolchildren. The Escondido Union School District has adopted a policy without parent input that places a communication barrier between parents and teachers ... For these parents, the new policy appears to undermine their own constitutional rights while it conflicts with knowledgeable medical opinion. An order enjoining the new district policy is in the better interests of the entire community, as well as the plaintiff teachers." -Judge Roger T. Benitez

[CaliforniaFamily.org] Earlier this year, two teachers sued Escondido Union School District (EUSD) and the state education board over policies that forced them to keep parents in the dark when it comes to students' intentions to "change" genders and socially "transition" at school. Recently, in a major victory for parents' rights, a federal judge has blocked the district from enforcing these policies. (Image: Pexels)

This initial ruling gives a huge legal shot in the arm to school boards who have been threatened by Attorney General Rob Bonta for passing notification policies that forbid teachers and administrators from keeping secret the gender identity of students from parents.

According to EUSD's policies, teachers are required to use students' "preferred pronouns" or chosen names during the school day, but when speaking with parents, teachers are instructed to use the students' biological pronouns and legal names.

Further, the district's policy prohibits "revealing a student's transgender status to individuals who do not have a legitimate need for the information, without the student's consent." The policy goes on to say that "parents or caretakers...do not have a legitimate need for the information," according to the lawsuit.

Judge Roger T. Benitez raised concerns regarding the constitutionality of this policy and issued an injunction preventing the district from enforcing it until the lawsuit has undergone the judicial process.

"Parental involvement [is] essential to the healthy maturation of schoolchildren," wrote Benitez. "The Escondido Union School District has adopted a policy withoutparentalinput that places a communication barrier between parents and teachers ... For these parents, the new policy appears to undermine their own constitutional rights while it conflicts with knowledgeable medical opinion. An order enjoining the new district policy is in the better interests of the entire community, as well as the plaintiff teachers."

Benitez also referenced transgender doctor Erica Anderson, who said that parents know their children best and are best able to determine if their child is grappling with gender dysphoria and how to handle it.

The judge went on to mention that children often make "impetuous and ill-considered life decisions," and that under the Constitution, parents have the right to direct their child's "education, health, and upbringing." He stated it was "unlikely" that constitutional rights to privacy for children include a "right of confidentiality from their own parents."

Finally, the order described the parental exclusion policies as a "trifecta of harm" and detailed the abuses it imposes on children, parents, and teachers.

Such policies harm "the child who needs parental guidance and possibly mental health intervention to determine if the incongruence is organic or whether it is the result of bullying, peer pressure, or a fleeting impulse. It harms the parents by depriving them of the long recognized Fourteenth Amendment right to care, guide, and make health care decisions for their children. And finally, it harms plaintiffs [teachers] who are compelled to violate the parent's rights by forcing plaintiffs to conceal information they feel is critical for the welfare of their students—violating plaintiffs' religious beliefs."

The teachers are being represented by Thomas More Society attorneys. "This is an untenable situation to put teachers in," explained Thomas More Society Special Counsel and Partner Paul M. Jonna. "Traditionally, educators have been viewed as highly significant players in a child's development, partnering with parents—not supplanting them—in the incredibly important responsibility of raising children. The State of California and the Escondido Union School District have created an unconscionable scenario where it pits these two key influencers in a child's life against one another by putting up an intentional curtain of dishonesty between them."

Jonna also noted on X, previously known as Twitter, that because of this major federal court victory, California school districts are "now on notice that policies that require teachers to hide information from parents about their students' gender identity violate the US Constitution."

This case is far from over, but the parental exclusion policy will be halted while the lawsuit proceeds in court.

Educators should never be required to deceive parents about information pertaining to their children's mental health. Not only is this a violation of parental rights, but it is also a violation of teachers' freedom of speech and religion. Further, children should not be left on their own to navigate difficult issues such as gender dysphoria. This ruling is a major step in the right direction for parental rights and children's safety in California. Subscribe for free to Breaking Christian News here







SHARE THIS ARTICLE Printer friendly version of this page

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

Other Recent Articles from Breaking Christian News

Watch: Woman Who Prayed While Dangling from Bridge in Semi-Truck Credits the Lord for Surviving Horrific Ordeal, Says, 'God Is Listening'

Fifth Grader Wins Battle to Begin School Prayer Club

Her Daughter Was Harassed By a Boy on the Girls' Team. Now, She's Speaking Out to Save Title IX

Women Defend Kansas City Chiefs Kicker

Judge Cannon Calls Jack Smith Out For His Dirty Tricks in Rare Sunday Order

Morehouse College Students Turn Their Backs on Biden during His Commencement Speech

Iran's President Dies in Helicopter Crash, Stirring Up More Mideast Volatility

Atheists Triggered by Billy Graham Statue in the US Capitol

Israel Pursues 'Critical' Rafah Battle, Defends against Legal Attack as Gaza Aid Pier Nears Completion

More Shady Biden Accounts Have Been Discovered

House Judiciary Votes to Hold AG Merrick Garland in Contempt of Congress

Fed Court: Parents in Maryland School District CANNOT Opt K-5 Children Out of LGBTQ Curriculum

Teacher Wins $360,000 Settlement after Being Fired for Refusing to Use Preferred Pronouns Because of Her Faith: 'Justice Is Served'

NFL Star Harrison Butker's Brave Commencement Speech Triggers the Left, Causing Them to Petition for Him to Be Fired; Others Call Him 'Hero'

UK Waking Up? Government to End Sex Education for Children Under Nine, and Teach That 'Gender Ideology' is Contested

'For Love of Country': Tulsi Gabbard Is Free from the Democrat Party She No Longer Recognizes

Soros-Linked DC Judge Releases Teen Gunman after He Sprayed Dozens of Shots at a Car

Kansas City Chiefs Kicker Slams Biden for Supporting Abortion in College Commencement Speech

Persecution of Pro-Life Americans Continues With This Week's Sentences in DC FACE Act Case

Senator Paul to Newsmax: Scientist Affirms Gain-of-Function in Wuhan, 'This Is a Really Big Deal'



Search the Articles Archives

Keyword:  
Author:  
Words Posted On:  
Day Month Year



BCN Plus

Follow BCN on Twitter
Are You Praying for Our Government Leaders?
BCN Staff

Steve Shultz
Steve Shultz, Managing Editor
Founder and Owner


Aimee Herd
Aimee Herd, Editor


BCN Plus
Are You Praying for President Trump?
 
 

All articles on this site and emails from BCN are copyrighted property of Breaking Christian News. Permission is given to link to, or share a BCN story if proper attribution is given to both the original writer and summarizer of the story. Breaking Christian News 2005-2019. All Rights Reserved.


Breaking Christian News is a division of Elijah List Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved


Disclaimer: Articles and links, as well as the source articles linked to; do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Breaking Christian News.

editor@breakingchristiannews.com