To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE


SHARE THIS ARTICLE Printer friendly version of this page

Supreme Court Vacates Ruling that Minors Have Constitutional 'Right' to Abortion; One Justice Dissents

Ben Johnson : Mar 22, 2023  The Washington Stand

"We are still seeing the trickle-down effects of the Dobbs decision—both saving unborn children's lives and now protecting the right of states to protect parental notification laws. When a minor is considering a decision as tragic, terrible, and dangerous as allowing an abortionist to kill her unborn child, her parents should be there to help their daughter choose life and to speak up in defense of their grandchild's life." -Mary Szoch, director of the Center for Human Dignity at Family Research Council

[WashingtonStand.com] The US Supreme Court has vacated a lower court's opinion asserting that underage girls possess a constitutional right to have an abortion without notifying their parents. Only one justice, Ketanji Brown Jackson, dissented that her colleagues effectively erased the pro-abortion decision from the books, preventing lawyers from citing it as a binding legal precedent in future cases. (Image: Pixabay)

Justices on Monday wiped out an appeals court's decision in the Chapman v. Doe case. In 2018, a 17-year-old referred to as "Jane Doe" sought a Missouri court ruling to bypass the state's law requiring that she obtain parental consent before undergoing an abortion. But a Randolph County court clerk named Michelle Chapman told the minor that the judge said her parents must be notified before the court hearing. Doe traveled to Illinois, where she received a judge's permission and underwent an abortion.

She then contracted the ACLU to sue Chapman for placing an "undue burden" on her unalienable "right" to abortion, violating the terms of Justice Anthony Kennedy's 1992 opinion in Casey v. Planned Parenthood.

Hearing Doe's case, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals contended last April that the right of a minor to bypass parental input or knowledge is an established part of US citizenship ... Doe's constitutional right to apply for a judicial bypass without notifying her parents is clearly established by Supreme Court precedent," said the appeals court. "Chapman's refusal to allow her to apply for a judicial bypass without parental notification violated her Fourteenth Amendment rights."

Two months later, the Supreme Court issued its Dobbs decision, which ruled that "procuring an abortion is not a fundamental constitutional right because such a right has no basis in the Constitution's text or in our [n]ation's history." Chapman and Dobbs agreed the decision made their case moot—but Chapman then appealed to have the lower court ruling thrown out.

In Chapman's legal filing, Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey (R) noted, since Roe v. Wade had not established a minor's right to obtain an abortion without her parents' involvement, the lower court's ruling "carries legal significance on parental notification requirements that this Court has not" established. Bailey requested the justices issue a vacated judgment, known as a "Munsingwear vacatur," which Bailey noted, "prevents the decision from spawning legal consequences for similarly situated persons."

Justices on Monday remanded the case to the Eighth Circuit with instructions to vacate and dismiss it as moot. That halts others from citing the Eighth Circuit's pro-abortion ruling as precedent in future cases.

"We are still seeing the trickle-down effects of the Dobbs decision—both saving unborn children's lives and now protecting the right of states to protect parental notification laws," Mary Szoch, director of the Center for Human Dignity at Family Research Council, told The Washington Stand. "When a minor is considering a decision as tragic, terrible, and dangerous as allowing an abortionist to kill her unborn child, her parents should be there to help their daughter choose life and to speak up in defense of their grandchild's life."

...Joe Biden's only Supreme Court appointee to date, Associate Justice Katanji Brown Jackson, issued the lone dissent. "[O]ur common-law system assumes that judicial decisions are valuable and should not be cast aside lightly, especially because judicial precedents 'are not merely the property of private litigants,' but also belong to the public and 'legal community as a whole,'" she wrote. She argued, since Chapman agreed the case was moot due to Dobbs, Dobbs did not play the definitive role in making the ruling moot.

Jackson represented NARAL Pro-Choice America, the League of Women Voters, and the Abortion Access Project of Massachusetts during the time she belonged to Boston's Goodwin Procter law firm.

Jackson also generated headlines during her confirmation hearings, when she said she felt incapable of defining the word "woman," because she is "not a biologist."

The issue of parental notification and consent for their young daughter's abortion continues to play a part of the national debate over parental rights, which has expanded to public school curriculum, school library book choices, and gender transitions.

The high court remains largely sympathetic to parental rights. Last June, Chief Justice John Roberts allowed Indiana to begin enforcing its parental notification law as the case made its way through the court system.

Yet lower courts remain mixed. A Montana judge permanently enjoined that state's parental consent law as "unconstitutional and unenforceable" last month but said a trial must determine the fate of its 2012 Notification Act. Lewis and Clark County District Court Judge Chris Abbott was appointed to the bench by former Governor Steve Bullock, a Democrat.

The debate has also engulfed potential judicial appointees. Democrats have signaled concern over Biden's appointment of Michael Delaney, nominated for the Boston-based First US Circuit Court of Appeals, because he once signed a petition for a parental notification case. As deputy attorney general of New Hampshire in 2005, Delaney signed a brief in Ayotte vs. Planned Parenthood of Northern New England, which required parents to be notified before minor daughters had an abortion.

Senator Richard Blumenthal (D-CT) said, since he sees abortion as "a fundamental, core issue ... I'd want to know why he put his name on the brief." Another, unnamed Democratic senator also told the Associated Press of their hesitancy because of Delaney signing the brief, and the National Council of Jewish Women opposes Delaney's nomination, saying his role in the 2006 Supreme Court ruling proves he lacks "fairness, independence, fidelity to constitutional values, and respect" for plaintiffs.

A total of 36 states require parental notification of one or both parents before an unemancipated minor can have an abortion, including 21 states that demand at least one parent's consent, but 35 of those states provide for a judicial bypass, according to the pro-abortion Guttmacher Institute.

"We should give thanks for the Dobbs decision that continues to positively impact other Supreme Court decisions and allows states to do whatever possible to protect the unborn," said Szoch. Subscribe for free to Breaking Christian News here

Ben Johnson is senior reporter and editor at The Washington Stand.







SHARE THIS ARTICLE Printer friendly version of this page

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

Other Recent Articles from Breaking Christian News

Prayer Alert: Missouri State Rep. Ben Baker's Daughter, Son-In-Law Shot Dead in Haiti After Attack by 'Gangs' While Serving as Missionaries

350 Hostages Rescued from Radical Islamic Boko Haram Jihadists in Nigeria

Trump's Rally in Deep Blue South Bronx Draws Enormous Crowd

Irony: Even Illegal Aliens Are Worried About 'Who Comes into This Country': 'Killers, Psychopaths'

House Passes Bill Barring Non-US Citizens from Voting in Local DC Elections

Justice Court Orders Israel to Stop War as IDF Recovers 3 More Hostage Bodies, 100 Still Captive

Oregon Threatens Parents Who Complain About Trans Athletes

New Study: People Who Undergo Transgender Surgery Are 12 Times More Likely to Commit Suicide

'God Was There That Day': Parents Reflect on Series of Miracles That Saved Drowning Daughters

Federal Judge Orders DC Transit Authority to Run Christian Ads It Had Rejected

UPDATED Explainer: WHO Pandemic Agreement Threatens National Sovereignty, Free Speech, and Life

Fauci's Flunky Admits to Deleting COVID Emails

Trump, Biden, and CNN: What to Know About the First Presidential Debate

Nikki Haley Reveals She 'Will Be Voting for Trump'

Shocking: Courageous J6 Political Prisoner Shares Deplorable, Life-Threatening Conditions Facing Prisoners at Metro Detention Center Brooklyn

Student Banned from Delivering Patriotic Speech over 'Inclusion' Concerns

Judge Judy Has a Scathing Message for Cities Engulfed in Brazen Crime, Pinpoints 'Ridiculous' Policies

BIDEN BORDER CRISIS: Eight Heinous Illegal Immigrant Crimes ABC/CBS/NBC Are Hiding

Norway, Ireland, Spain to Recognize Palestinian State; Israel Fights Efforts to Handcuff Jewish State

US-Built Pier in Gaza an Epic Failure, as UN Lets Hamas Steal Most of the Aid



Search the Articles Archives

Keyword:  
Author:  
Words Posted On:  
Day Month Year



BCN Plus

Follow BCN on Twitter
Are You Praying for Our Government Leaders?
BCN Staff

Steve Shultz
Steve Shultz, Managing Editor
Founder and Owner


Aimee Herd
Aimee Herd, Editor


BCN Plus
Are You Praying for President Trump?
 
 

All articles on this site and emails from BCN are copyrighted property of Breaking Christian News. Permission is given to link to, or share a BCN story if proper attribution is given to both the original writer and summarizer of the story. Breaking Christian News 2005-2019. All Rights Reserved.


Breaking Christian News is a division of Elijah List Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved


Disclaimer: Articles and links, as well as the source articles linked to; do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Breaking Christian News.

editor@breakingchristiannews.com