To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE
Florida's Education Choice Opportunity
Jason Bedrick : Mar 13, 2023 The Daily Signal
"School choice empowers parents, creates competition, fosters innovation, and raises the level of excellence in all of our schools. HB 1 will give every parent the freedom to customize their children's education with a learning program that fits their unique needs." -Florida House Speaker Paul Renner
[DailySignal.com] Florida long has been a leading state for education freedom and choice. It was no surprise when Florida ranked first in the nation last year in The Heritage Foundation's inaugural Education Freedom Report Card. (Image: Pexels)
"Florida's schoolchildren are thriving because we invest in our students, and we empower parents to decide what learning environment is best for their kids," Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, a Republican, said at an event launching Heritage's report card. (The Daily Signal is the multimedia news organization of The Heritage Foundation.)
Florida has provided other states with a model of education policy worth emulating. However, as DeSantis conceded during his remarks, Florida didn't take the top spot in every category.
The Sunshine State ranked third for education choice behind Arizona and Indiana, because of their more robust policies.
"We're going to be working hard to make sure we do even better going forward," DeSantis declared.
Since then, three additional states—Iowa, Utah, and Arkansas—have overtaken Florida by enacting education choice policies for which all K-12 students will be eligible. Several other states are considering such universal policies.
If Florida lawmakers want to take the school choice crown, they likewise will have to expand education choice to all students.
A proposal now before the Florida Legislature would do just that. House Bill 1, a priority bill for Florida House Speaker Paul Renner, a Republican, would expand eligibility for the state's groundbreaking education savings account policy to all K-12 students. Currently, only students with special needs are eligible.
With an education savings account, or ESA, families have the freedom and flexibility to customize their child's education. Families may use ESA funds to pay for private school tuition, tutoring, textbooks, homeschool curriculum, online learning, special needs therapy, and more. Florida was the second state, after Arizona, to enact an ESA policy.
"School choice empowers parents, creates competition, fosters innovation, and raises the level of excellence in all of our schools," Renner said. "HB 1 will give every parent the freedom to customize their children's education with a learning program that fits their unique needs."
Expanding eligibility for Florida's education savings accounts to all K-12 students would be a major step toward ensuring that every child gets access to the education he or she deserves. However, the legislation has some areas that need improvement.
As written, HB 1 would allow families to use ESAs to pay for online learning. However, the bill—perhaps inadvertently—references an existing statute that requires that an "approved provider" of virtual education must be "nonsectarian in its programs, admission policies, employment practices, and operations." In other words, whereas ESA families could choose religious or secular private schools, tutors, and other education providers, they would be prohibited from choosing religiously affiliated providers of virtual learning.
Not only would this prohibition unnecessarily restrict parental choice, but it almost certainly runs afoul of the First Amendment's free exercise clause, as made clear in recent Supreme Court decisions in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue and Carson v. Makin.
In Espinoza, the high court ruled that a state "need not subsidize private education" but that once it "decides to do so, it cannot disqualify some private schools solely because they are religious." Likewise, a state need not subsidize families choosing virtual learning, but once it decides to do so, it cannot disqualify some virtual learning providers solely because they are religious.
Another issue concerns the definition of "eligible private school." Those who travel down the rabbit hole of statutory references will find that eligible private schools must provide full-time, in-person instruction. However, this would limit the ability of parents to choose "blended learning" programs that combine or alternate between in-person and virtual instruction, as well as "hybrid homeschooling" that alternates between in-person instruction and home education.
Given the unnecessarily long school shutdowns during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the uneven quality of "Zoom school," state policymakers understandably are keen to ensure that families have access to in-person instruction.
However, policymakers should not unnecessarily restrict families' learning options. For a variety of legitimate reasons, some families prefer virtual options or the combination of virtual and in-person instruction.
It's also important to remember that emergency distance learning isn't the same thing as intentional virtual learning programs.
A 2020 survey found that 86% of parents of children enrolled in virtual schools reported that their children "learned a lot." Meanwhile, only 13% of parents of children enrolled in brick-and-mortar schools that were using remote learning reported that their children had "learned a lot."
The survey also found that parents of virtual-school students were "significantly more likely to report that their child engaged in activities associated with active learning, and they agreed that virtual schools outperformed brick and mortar schools when it comes to clear communication, classroom management, and sound instructional practices."
Even before COVID-19, some private schools began to incorporate virtual learning into their programming in order to expand students' access to subjects they otherwise could not offer, to improve quality, and to reduce costs.
For example, as I previously detailed in an essay for Mosaic, blended learning is increasingly common among parochial schools serving the Orthodox Jewish community, which is making an exodus to Florida from states such as New York due, in large part, to Florida's school choice policies. Likewise, virtual learning is a particular boon to rural schools that might struggle to find local teachers for certain advanced or uncommon coursework, like Advanced Placement Calculus or Mandarin Chinese.
As written, HB 1 would limit the ability of these schools to provide virtual instruction.
Fortunately, policymakers could fix these issues easily by inserting language into the bill clarifying that, notwithstanding any other provision in Florida statute, families using education savings accounts may choose virtual learning providers that offer sectarian or nonsectarian instruction. The language also should specify that virtual learning counts toward students' regular attendance, whether or not they also are enrolled in a brick-and-mortar school.
Florida has an opportunity to reclaim its mantle as the leading state for education freedom and choice. With just a few small but important tweaks, the Sunshine State could adopt a policy on universal education choice that will be a shining example for other states to follow. Subscribe for free to Breaking Christian News here
Jason Bedrick is a research fellow with The Heritage Foundation's Center for Education Policy.
To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE
Other Recent Articles from Breaking Christian News
72-Hour Revival at Baylor Leads to 20+ Baptisms: 'A Compelling Invitation to Know Jesus'
Erin Brewer Explains the Connection Between Childhood Trauma and Gender Dysphoria
Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds Signs Law Banning 'Gender Transitions' for Children, Males in Female Bathrooms
World Athletics Bans Transgender Athletes from Competing in Female Sports
House Fails to Override Biden's First Presidential Veto over Woke ESG Investment Rule
Senator Rand Paul Probes State Dep't Funding for Coronavirus Research: 'The American Public Needs to Know'
Federal Appeals Court Blocks Biden's Vaccine Mandate for US Government Workers
'Predators' Use TikTok to 'Groom Our Kids,' Chaya Raichik Says in Calling for National Ban on the Chinese App
Iran Proxy Forces Fire Multiple Rockets on US Base in Northeast Syria Following US Retaliatory Strikes after Iranian Drone Killed US Contractor
'This is Big, Folks': Kari Lake Scores a Victory from Arizona Supreme Court
Many Are Escaping Iran, and 'Hundreds Have Come to Faith in Jesus Christ' in the Process
Netanyahu: 'No Law' Will Pass in Knesset That 'Harms Christianity'
COVID in the 2030s: How Endless Booster Shots Will Devastate the Health of Our Children
Federal Agency Contradicts Biden, Says Student Loan Cancellation Not in Effect
Daily Signal Exclusive: GOP Bill Would Make Abortionists Report Victims of Trafficking
Is This the Bombshell Evidence That Destroyed Bragg's Case against Trump?
Trans-'Woman' (Biological Male) Finishes in First Place at New York City Women's Cycling Event, Sparks Anger
Ugandan Parliament Passes 'Anti-Homosexuality Bill,' Infuriating the Pro-LGBT West
'Cusp of Great Spiritual Awakening': Pastors Report Fresh 'Fire' in Wake of Methodist Mass Exodus
Ohio's Proposed New Abortion Amendment Will Take the State Back to the 'Dark Ages', Say Faith Leaders (VIDEO)
Search the Articles Archives
All articles on this site and emails from BCN are copyrighted property of Breaking Christian News. Permission is given to link to, or share a BCN story if proper attribution is given to both the original writer and summarizer of the story. Breaking Christian News 2005-2019. All Rights Reserved.
Breaking Christian News is a division of Elijah List Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: Articles and links, as well as the source articles linked to; do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Breaking Christian News.
|Home | Store | Subscribe | Facebook | Article Archive|