|
To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE
Good News: Canada's Top Court Sides with Religious Groups, says They're 'Free' to Make their Own Rules
Editor's Note: While this lawsuit involved Jehovah's Witnesses, the ruling would apply to any religious group in Canada, including Christian churches. As the ARPA of Canada stated regarding the decision: "This case will stand as a clear precedent protecting the independence of religious bodies. It will also stand as a reminder to all judges of the virtue of judicial humility." -Aimee Herd, BCN (Ottawa)— [LifeSiteNews.com] Canada's top court has affirmed the right of religious groups to govern their own affairs. It ruled yesterday that an Alberta court had no jurisdiction to review a decision by a Jehovah's Witness congregation to expel a member for alleged drunkenness and domestic verbal abuse. (Photo credit: Shutterstock/via LifeSiteNews) In a 30-page ruling released Thursday, all nine Supreme Court justices agreed the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench had no authority to rule on civil action against Jehovah's Witness brought by former member Randy Wall. The plaintiff had argued that his expulsion from the church affected his property and civil rights. Courts have neither the "legitimacy nor institutional capacity to deal with contentious matters of religious doctrine," wrote Justice Malcolm Rowe. "In the end, religious groups are free to determine their own membership and rules," Rowe concluded, adding courts will only intervene in such matters if there is an underlying legal dispute that must be resolved, reported the National Post. A Calgary-based independent realtor, Wall was "disfellowshipped" by the elders of the Highwood Congregation of the Jehovah's Witnesses congregation in 2014 for insufficient repentance. Wall had admitted to two incidents of drunkenness and one of verbally abusing his wife, but contended he was under stress because his 15-year-old daughter's previous expulsion from the congregation led him to evict her from the family home, according to a summary of the case in the Court of Appeal of Alberta ruling. When his appeal to church bodies failed, Wall applied to the court to overturn the decision, arguing the expulsion affected him financially because half his clients were members of Jehovah's Witness congregations and had severed ties with him, the Post reported. A judge ruled the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench had jurisdiction to rule on the matter because the disfellowship had an economic impact on Wall, and the Court of Appeal upheld that decision in September 2016. The Highwood congregation appealed to the Supreme Court, which heard the case on November 2, 2017. A number of faith and civil liberties groups intervened in the case on behalf of the Highwood congregation. Several hailed Thursday's ruling as a victory for religious and free association rights. "Mr. Justice Rowe's reasons provide a strong statement on the limited role courts should have on reviewing internal decisions of private institutions, and in particular, ecclesiastical bodies," said Philip Horgan, a Toronto-based constitutional lawyer and president of Catholic Civil Right League. "We are pleased with the court's analysis of the limited role for judicial review of such institutional decisions, and the further recognition that secular courts are not qualified to rule on theological or ecclesiastical concerns"... Continue reading here. 
To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE
Other Recent Articles from Breaking Christian News Countdown for Historic Space Mission Artemis II Begins Trump Rolls Out a Plan to Back Farmers amid Rising Costs, Pledging 'Golden Age' Trump's Election Executive Order is Causing a Meltdown among Liberals Another Illegal Alien Charged With Murder in Democrat Run Fairfax County, Virginia US Forces Reach 12,000 Combat Flights, Debunk Fake News About Iran Operation President Trump Addresses Nation Tonight, Signals End in Sight for Iran Conflict Supreme Court Hears Arguments on Birthright Citizenship, as the CCP Exploits It to Sway US Elections Trump's FDA Indicates Move Away from Testing on Dogs, Bunnies, Chimpanzees Chicago Bulls Dump Player after His Criticism of Pride Month Finally Confirmed: Michigan Synagogue Car Ramming Was 'Hezbollah-Inspired' Terror Attack SURPRISE! Zohran Mamdani's New 'Free' Childcare Program is Going to Cost $60,000 Per Child Courtroom Bombshell: ATF Can't Link Bullet That Killed Charlie Kirk to Suspect's Rifle SCOTUS Rules on Colorado's Ban on 'Conversion Therapy' to Help Gender Dysphoric Individuals President Trump Shares Letter on Palm Sunday, from Franklin Graham Discussing Salvation HSLDA Lawyer Warns This Bill Would Create a 'Surveillance State' for Homeschooling Families Major Airports Return to Normal as TSA Workers Get Paid GROTESQUE: Barack Obama's Orwellian Push for Virginia Redistricting Is Something to Behold |
Subscribe to
|
"The Supreme Court's ruling provides clarity to Canadians that neither courts nor governments can legally compel citizens to associate together unwillingly." -John Carpay, JCCF President
All articles on this site and emails from BCN are copyrighted property of Breaking Christian News. Permission is given to link to, or share a BCN story if proper attribution is given to both the original writer and summarizer of the story. Breaking Christian News 2005-2019. All Rights Reserved.
Breaking Christian News is a division of Elijah List Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: Articles and links, as well as the source articles linked to; do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Breaking Christian News.
| Home | Store | Subscribe | Facebook | Article Archive |