Care Net, a national non-profit ministry supporting one of the largest networks of pregnancy centers in the United States, filed an amicus brief to support National Institute of Family and Life Advocates in that case. In the brief, Care Net's attorneys argue it is directly impacted by, and deeply concerned about, California's decision to force pregnancy centers to become spokespersons for the abortion industry.

In a press release announcing the filing, Care Net officials state:

The amicus brief clearly lays out the reasons the Reproductive FACT Act creates compelled-speech regulations that must be reversed. The regulations force pregnancy centers to promote an idea—abortion —that they believe puts their clients at risk; and the regulations force pregnancy centers to engage in unnecessary speech that dilutes the centers' own communications and messages. Such regulations would be akin to a state requiring Alcoholics Anonymous, whose mission is to encourage those it serves to abstain from drinking, to provide listings of nearby bars and liquor stores.

Additionally, the compelled-speech regulations also violate the Free Exercise Clause, which protects religiously-motivated groups and individuals from being singled out and targeted by the government. Given that the Reproductive FACT Act's scope is defined to apply only to facilities "whose primary purpose is providing pregnancy-related services," it is clear that California targeted religion and religious practices. For example, places such as hospitals that provide non-pregnancy-related services are exempt from the law even though they also offer the same pregnancy-related services that pro-life pregnancy centers do. Lukimi Babalu Aye v. City of Hialeah prohibits such religious targeting.

Finally, pro-choice activists should be against these regulations, too. If the government can take sides on a political debate and force people or organizations to express ideas that they disagree with or find morally objectionable, then it could force abortion clinics to post signs informing pregnant mothers that the clinic does not provide live-birth deliveries or support for mothers choosing to continue their pregnancies, directing these women to nearby pregnancy resource centers where they could reconsider their decision. Such regulations must be invalidated by the Supreme Court.

In conclusion, the brief argues that the Supreme Court should grant the petition, reverse the Ninth Circuit, and invalidate California's compelled-speech regulations because they "fail to respect a [pregnancy resource center's] right not to utter a state-sponsored message that offends its core moral and religious principles" (Greater Baltimore Center for Pregnancy Concerns, Inc. v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore), and because they violate the Free Exercise Clause (Lukimi Babalu Aye v. City of Hialeah).

"Clearly, this law is promoted by pro-choice activists and those in the abortion industry to silence any voices that oppose their agenda," Care Net CEO Roland C. Warren said. "Sadly, this unconstitutional violation of free speech and religious freedom was signed into law and upheld by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. We support NIFLA's petition to reverse this decision in the Supreme Court, allowing pregnancy centers and other life-affirming organizations to continue their life-saving work without state interference."

Charisma News

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

New Animated 'JESUS' Film Announced for Worldwide Release

Christian Trucking Company Fined $700K by Biden's 'Justice' Department, Wait Till You Read Why...

Apple TV Star Condemns Progressives for Blind Support of Hamas, Shares No-Holds-Barred Opinion

Update: IDF Hits 200 Hamas Terror Targets as Gaza Ground Op Expands

CA Mom Begs SCOTUS to Protect Parental Rights after Gender-Confused Daughter's Suicide

Utah State QB Chooses to Forgo His Final Season to Become a Different Kind of Hero

Danielle Smith Warns Trudeau Government She's Going Ahead With Natural Gas Projects Despite Regulations

DeSantis DOMINATES in Red State-Blue State Governors Debate With Newsom [Video]

Trial Date Set: Court Docs Say VA Election Official 'Altered Election Results' in 2020 Election

Deutsche Bank May Have Just Destroyed Letitia James' Civil Fraud Case against Trump

Rep George Santos Expelled from Congress

Former Justice O'Connor, First Woman to Serve on US Supreme Court Dies at 93

Israeli Hostages Recount Beatings, Death Threats in Captivity

IDF Resumes Combat in Gaza after Hamas Violates Ceasefire

Religious Freedom Victory: US Capitol Tree Removes Ban on Ornaments Displaying 'Religious Symbols' from Being Displayed on the 2023 Tree

Lack of 'Affirmation' Is Child Abuse: New Biden Rule Applies Transgender Standard to Foster Care

Poll Shows Nationwide Support for Parental Notification Policies in Schools

US House Proposes Bill Defunding Planned Parenthood, Banning 'Sex Changes' With Taxpayer Dollars

Hamas Hostage's Mother Shares Horrific Details of What She Heard During Terror Attack, Her Warning to the World

Three Killed, 6 Wounded in Jerusalem Terror Attack as Gaza Cease-Fire Extended Another Day