To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE
MRC Warns Trump Admin: AI-Media Contracts Infusing Leftist Bias in AI, Report"The concern I have—and this may seem like a small concern, but I think it's actually a very big, big issue—is that they are not maximally truth-seeking. They're pandering to political correctness." -Elon Musk
MRC President David Bozell warned the Trump administration of this very phenomenon in letters to Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Director Russell Vought and Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Chairman Andrew Ferguson on Wednesday. In the letters, Bozell called attention to top AI companies' training data agreements with predominantly left-leaning legacy media outlets (59% left-leaning vs. 5% right-leaning). He also asked Vought to clarify whether these contracts violate a recent executive order by President Donald Trump and requested that Ferguson investigate whether the AI firms' contracts constitute anti-competitive and unfair practices that could distort the marketplace. OpenAI has opted to train ChatGPT with outlets like The Washington Post, The Atlantic, Financial Times, Vox Media and others. Amazon has similarly made an agreement to use The New York Times and Google has contracted with The Associated Press. News Corp, which has a contract with ChatGPT, is the only right-leaning media group that has this type of contract with a major AI company. Up until now, these contracts have gone on without a hitch despite President Trump's recent executive order promoting ideological neutrality. But Amazon, Google, Meta, Microsoft and OpenAI's 97 agreements with media entities are anything but neutral. In the letter to OMB Director Vought, Bozell explained: "The Media Research Center's analysis found that AI platforms are contracting with left-leaning outlets over ten times more often than with outlets rated 'lean right' or 'right' by AllSides. These contracts—such as those between OpenAI and The Atlantic or The Associated Press—limit competition, reinforce a single ideological perspective, and undermine the diversity of information essential to neutral AI outputs." [Emphasis added.] Indeed, OpenAI has more contracts with media outlets than any other top AI company, and an MRC analysis found that only two of its agreements are with media outlets AllSides rates as "right" (Fox News) or "lean right" (the New York Post). Meanwhile, OpenAI has made deals with at least 21 media outlets AllSides deems left-leaning. This raises many legal questions. In his letter to FTC Chairman Ferguson, Bozell noted that, "Courts have upheld the right to use publicly available material for AI training, suggesting these exclusive agreements are unnecessary and may exist primarily to funnel payments to favored outlets." [Emphasis added.] These contracts further bring up antitrust concerns because they "consolidate influence in a few legacy voices [and] reduce market diversity." Bozell continued, adding, "Big Tech's selective contracting, combined with its political influence and push for stricter copyright enforcement, appears designed to block new competitors and entrench control over information markets." As such, the MRC asked that the FTC to "immediately investigate whether Big Tech's artificial intelligence firms are engaging in anti-competitive and unfair practices by contracting almost exclusively with ideologically aligned media outlets. " Given these AI platforms' overt reliance on left-leaning sources, MRC also asked that OMB offer guidance clarifying whether the AI companies' "intentional use of a narrow set of biased sources" in their training data "violates the ideological neutrality requirement in President Donald Trump's recent Executive Order on AI." Bozell additionally stressed the need for action noting the "hundreds of millions of dollars recently awarded in federal defense contracts to AI companies." As Bozell repeatedly emphasized in his letters, the impact of these contracts is significant given that excluding diversity in artificial intelligence training data would have the effect of biasing its results. It seems both tech CEOs and politicians are well aware of this. During a roundtable event, former Vice President Kamala Harris said the quiet part out loud. "[T]he machine is taught—and part of the issue here is what information is going into the machine that will then determine—and we can predict then, if we think about what information is going in, what then will be produced in terms of decisions and opinions that may be made through that process." Open AI CEO Sam Altman made a similar admission when he testified before the Senate in 2023, saying that "one of my areas of greatest concern" is "[t]he more general ability of [AI] models to manipulate, to persuade, [and] to provide sort of one-on-one interactive disinformation." Google CEO Sundar Pichai also stated in a 2021 interview with Yahoo! Finance that bias review is "extraordinarily important" and that "studying for bias needs to be done up front" to ensure fairness. Just last year, Elon Musk similarly acknowledged a growing problem OpenAI's ChatGPT and Google's Gemini were experiencing. "The concern I have—and this may seem like a small concern, but I think it's actually a very big, big issue—is that they are not maximally truth-seeking. They're pandering to political correctness." Subscribe for free to Breaking Christian News here MRC contributor Zackory Langin contributed to this report Methodology: For the analysis, MRC researchers cross-referenced Amazon, Google, Meta, Microsoft and OpenAI's 97* agreements with media entities with AllSides' political bias ratings. AllSides had rated 39 of the media entities. Researchers then tallied how AllSides rated the 39* entities. AllSides rated 21 as "left" or "lean-left," 14 as "center" and two as "right" or "lean right." *OpenAI and Google both have contracts with The Associated Press (which is rated by AllSides) and OpenAI and Microsoft both have contracts with Harper Collins (which is not rated by AllSides). The above numbers reflect that these were counted separately.
To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE
Other Recent Articles from Breaking Christian News Number of Young People Identifying as 'Non-Binary' Declines Sharply: Report Christian Photographer Scores Major Victory in LGBTQ Battle MRC Warns Trump Admin: AI-Media Contracts Infusing Leftist Bias in AI, Report The New Editor-in-Chief of CBS News Is Not Like the Others Rutgers Leader Demands TPUSA Officers Be Ousted after They Called Out Antifa-Linked Professor Speaker Johnson: Democrats Demanding $3.9M for LGBTQI+ in Western Balkans to Reopen Government Trump Warns Hamas to Disarm or Be Disarmed; Israel Demands Faster Return of Hostage Bodies Melania Trump Reveals She's Worked With Putin for Months to Reunite Ukrainian Children With Families Christians Fill Mile-Long Communion Table on National Mall: 'Nothing but the Blood of Jesus' Loudoun County Can't Suspend Boys Opposed to Girl in Locker Room; Judge Extends Block On Purging Woke Indoctrination from American Universities Special Envoy Richard Grenell on Peace Deal: Trump Is the 'Greatest Dealmaker Ever' Here's How Trump Forced Hamas to Accept the Peace Deal Columbus Day Honors Our Civilization … Which Is the Real Reason Critics Hate It Pastor Ché Ahn Looks to Bring 'Revival and Reformation' to California Governor's Race A Cuban-American Takes on Socialist Zohran Mamdani Search the Articles Archives |
All articles on this site and emails from BCN are copyrighted property of Breaking Christian News. Permission is given to link to, or share a BCN story if proper attribution is given to both the original writer and summarizer of the story. Breaking Christian News 2005-2019. All Rights Reserved.
Breaking Christian News is a division of Elijah List Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: Articles and links, as well as the source articles linked to; do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Breaking Christian News.
Home | Store | Subscribe | Facebook | Article Archive |