Alliance Defending Freedom attorneys representing Jessica Bates filed a lawsuit in April 2023 challenging an Oregon Department of Human Services rule that categorically excluded her from adopting any child—no matter their age or beliefs—because she would not lie to children and tell them that girls can be boys and vice versa. Bates asked the 9th Circuit to lift the state's gender-ideology exclusion and allow her to re-apply to adopt, free of discrimination, while her lawsuit continues. The court ordered ODHS to reconsider Bates' application because she will likely succeed in showing that Oregon's exclusion violates the First Amendment.

"Every child deserves a loving home, and children suffer when the government excludes people of faith from the adoption and foster system. Jessica is a caring mom of five who is now free to adopt after Oregon officials excluded her because of her common-sense belief that a girl cannot become a boy or vice versa," said ADF Senior Counsel and Vice President of Litigation Strategy Jonathan Scruggs, who argued before the court on behalf of Bates. "Because caregivers like Jessica cannot promote Oregon's dangerous gender ideology to young kids and take them to events like pride parades, the state considers them to be unfit parents. That is false and incredibly dangerous, needlessly depriving kids of opportunities to find a loving home. The 9th Circuit was right to remind Oregon that the foster and adoption system is supposed to serve the best interests of children, not the state's ideological crusade."

"No one thinks, for example, that a state could exclude parents from adopting foster children based on those parents' political views, race, or religious affiliations," the 9th Circuit wrote in its ruling in Bates v. Pakseresht. "Adoption is not a constitutional law dead zone. And a state's general conception of the child's best interest does not create a force field against the valid operation of other constitutional rights."

Bates applied to become certified to adopt children from foster care two years ago. Oregon's DHS, the agency that oversees child welfare programs, denied her application because Bates could not agree to use inaccurate pronouns to refer to a child or to take children to pride parades.

Although Bates told ODHS officials that she would happily love and accept any child placed with her, officials rejected her application, making her ineligible to adopt any child—even infants or children who share her religious beliefs.

In January, a broad coalition of foster and adoptive parents, religious liberty groups, free speech and family advocates, 20 states, and detransitioners filed friend-of-the-court briefs with the 9th Circuit in support of Bates. The briefs joined ADF in arguing that ODHS' policy needlessly penalizes Bates and many other people of faith for their religious views, compels parents to speak words that violate their conscience, and deprives children in need of the opportunity to find loving homes.

Rebekah Schultheiss, one of more than 4,800 attorneys in the ADF Attorney Network, serves as local counsel on behalf of Bates. Subscribe for free to Breaking Christian News here

Alliance Defending Freedom is an alliance-building, non-profit legal organization committed to protecting religious freedom, free speech, parental rights, and the sanctity of life.

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

Columbus Day Honors Our Civilization … Which Is the Real Reason Critics Hate It

Pastor Ché Ahn Looks to Bring 'Revival and Reformation' to California Governor's Race

A Cuban-American Takes on Socialist Zohran Mamdani

5 Key Takeaways from Last Week's Virginia Governor Debate

9th Circuit Rejects Gender-Ideology Mandate for Adoption; Oregon Mom Now Free to Care for Kids in Need

China Launches Surprise Attack on World Markets, Trump Threatens 'Massive' Tariff Response

President Trump Receives Israeli Presidential Medal of Honor for Bringing Hostages Home

20 Living Israeli Hostages Reunite with Loved ones; President Trump in Israel: 'The War is Over'

A TURNING POINT: Communion America

TPUSA Announces Counter to Bad Bunny Super Bowl Halftime Appearance: The 'All American Halftime Show'

Pastor Prays for Pizza Driver Who Delivered Wrong Order, Ring Cam Video Goes Viral

'Warmhearted Security Guard' and Churchgoer Beaten to Death on NYC Subway by Maniac with 33 Prior Arrests

'It's Not Looking Good' for Biden's Auto-Pen Pardons, House Oversight Chair Comer Reports

DOJ Charges NY AG Letitia James With Fraud: 'One Tier of Justice for All Americans'

Nobel Laureate Machado Honors President Trump as She Receives Peace Prize

Israel Prepares to Welcome Trump, Receive Hostages, as Phase 1 of Peace Deal Goes into Effect

End of the War? Trump and Netanyahu Say Hamas Has Agreed to Release Hostages

8 Faith-Filled Films, TV Shows to Watch This Fall, from 'Soul On Fire' to 'House Of David'

'Big Shift': Men Now Surpass Women in Church Attendance, Especially among Gen X, Millennials, Says Barna

Victory: Arkansas Student Will Be Able to Share His Faith during Social Time