In 2016, Judge Bunning dismissed all three 2015 marriage license lawsuits against her. In 2017, Bunning ruled that neither Kim Davis nor Rowan County were liable for attorney's fees over the marriage license issue that began in 2015. In 2019, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals issued two opinions in reversing and remanding the cases for further consideration. The cases of Ermold v. Davis, Yates v. Davis, and Miller v. Davis center on whether the plaintiffs are entitled to attorney fees and/or damages, and, if so, whether the Commonwealth, Rowan County or Kim Davis is liable for payment.

In the Miller appeal, the Sixth Circuit ruled that the Commonwealth of Kentucky is liable for attorney's fees, not the county, nor Kim Davis. In the Ermold appeal, the court agrees with lower court Judge Bunning—that Davis in her official capacity has sovereign immunity because she acted for the state (not the county). However, the Court ruled that Kim Davis has no qualified immunity as an individual. The Court noted that the case is at a very "early" stage and that no discovery has been conducted on this issue.

When Governor Matt Bevin took office in December 2015, he immediately issued an executive order accommodating all Kentucky clerks who refused to issue marriage licenses that conflict with their religious beliefs. Then in 2016, the Kentucky General Assembly unanimously passed legislation that provided accommodation for clerks who object to issuing marriage licenses for same-sex ceremonies.

In fact, (1) Kentucky has a history of accommodating clerks who chose to opt out of issuing hunting and fishing licenses; (2) Gov. Beshear accommodated the religious and conscientious objection of his attorney general who requested to opt out of defending the marriage law; (3) Gov. Matt Bevin accommodated Kim Davis and other clerks the first week he took office; and (4) the Kentucky General Assembly unanimously passed a law accommodating all clerks with religious objections by permitting them to opt out of issuing such licenses. Therefore, the refusal of Gov. Beshear to accommodate Kim Davis violated her First Amendment free exercise rights.

When Davis petitioned the Supreme Court for review in 2020, the High Court denied review in which the only issue raised was sovereign immunity. However, Justices Thomas and Alito appeared to invite future challenges to the 2015 Obergefell marriage case. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, wrote that "[t]his petition implicates important questions about the scope of our decision in Obergefell, but it does not cleanly present them."

In granting summary judgment for the plaintiffs, Judge Bunning ruled that Davis violated "clearly established" law when she ceased issuing all marriage licenses. The case will now proceed to trial on the issue of damages, if any. Davis argues that a finding of liability would violate the First Amendment Free Exercise of Religion.

This case now clearly presents the free exercise defense and thus could return to the Supreme Court.

Liberty Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver said, "Kim Davis is entitled to protection to an accommodation based on her sincere religious belief. This case raises serious First Amendment free exercise of religion claims and has a high potential of reaching the Supreme Court." Subscribe for free to Breaking Christian News here

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

America Reads the Bible' Kicks Off in DC in Record-Breaking Fashion

Sweden Rethinks Digital Learning, Returns to 'Old-Fashioned' Books in Effort to Reverse Poor Literacy

Supreme Court Rejects Parents' Challenge to Massachusetts School Trans Policy

Gay Couple Face Online Fury for Video Making Fun of Crying Baby: 'There Is No Mama'

The Electoral College and the Popular Vote

The DOJ Has Found HOW MANY Dead People on Voter Rolls?

President Donald Trump to Read Scripture during America Reads the Bible; Issues Historic Message About the Bible's 'Enduring Guidance'

US Military Boards Iranian Ship in Gulf; Trump Threatens No More 'Mr. Nice Guy' if Talks Fail

Long Beach, California Cancels Their Popular July 4th Fireworks Show, Even for America's 250th Birthday, Citing Pollution as the Reason

Digital Nightmare? Anthropic Withholds AI Model Too Dangerous for Humanity

'A Victory for All Pro-Life Oregonians': Federal Judge Rules State Can't Force Oregon Right to Life to Pay for Abortions

10 Republicans Side With Dems to Provide Amnesty to Haitian Illegals

Virginia Dems Pass National Popular Vote Law that Experts Warn Is Unconstitutional

Israel-Lebanon Ceasefire Begins; Trump Says Iran's Regime Agrees to Give Up Having Nuclear Weapons

President Trump: Strait of Hormuz 'Fully Open', Oil Prices Drop

Clarence Thomas Destroys 'Progressivism' in Ruthless Speech

Trump Reveals He Has Multi-Pick SCOTUS Plan Ready as Justice Retirement Speculation Heats Up

Trump Admin Pushes Global Plan to Protect Kids Online

Youth Mental Health Deteriorates after Gender Reassignment Services, Extensive, Long-Term Study Finds

Trump Administration Pulls $11 Million in Funding for Catholic Charities that Sheltered Illegal Alien Minors