In an extraordinary Order issued [this week], the Court directs the parties to file supplemental briefs that specifically address how the contraceptive and abortifacient coverage mandated by the Obama Administration might still be obtained by religious objectors' employees in a way that would not involve the objectors in any way in the process—including submitting the form that is required under the current HHS Mandate and is at the center of the current controversy.
 
Not only does the Court direct the parties to submit supplemental briefs no later than April 12th, the Court provides a detailed example of a procedure in which the Little Sisters' moral dilemma would be addressed in a way that (the Court suggests) might be morally acceptable to the Sisters while, at the same time, achieving the government's stated goal of removing barriers to contraceptive access. The Order does not present the parties with a "take it or leave it" example; instead, the Court invites the parties to come up with "other proposals along similar lines."
 
This is an extraordinary and hopeful development. While most observers of last Wednesday's oral argument on the case walked away believing that the Court was split 4-4—a result that would have meant a loss for the Little Sisters and others who lost at the courts of appeal—[This week's] development appears to indicate that the Court is, instead, struggling to fashion a resolution of the case that both sides can live with. Perhaps, in hindsight, there were hints of unease among even some of the liberal members of the Court last week when they were visibly surprised by what appeared to be the government's acknowledgment that the HHS Mandate did, in fact, impose a "substantial burden" on religious liberty. (Screengrab via Little Sisters of the Poor/YouTube)

Such an acknowledgment (later denied, somewhat weakly, by the government's lawyer) would trigger an obligation by the government to pursue its objectives by means that would be the "least restrictive" upon the Sisters' religious liberty. What today's Order suggests, if nothing else, is that there may be a majority of the Court that, in pondering the implications of this case, is grappling with the realization that there are, in fact, less restrictive means available to the government, one of which is outlined in today's Order itself.
 
All in all, we are pleased to see that the Court is viewing the religious liberty claims at stake here with the utmost seriousness and is taking this extraordinary step of directing the parties to help it craft a resolution that will truly respect and preserve our First Freedom.

Reprinted with permission from ACLJ.org.

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

Pakistani Christians Rally for Equal Rights

New York Town Bans Christians from Erecting Displays in Public, While Allowing Islamic and Other Symbols

Artificial Ignorance: The Political Falsehoods of Leading AIs

Mom and Daughter Forced to Cover 'XX/XY' Shirts at State Farm Arena in Support of Sophie Cunningham, While Pro-Trans Message Appeared on Jumbotron (Video)

Iran: 60-Day Ceasefire Ends, Trump Confirms IRGC Backchannel Peace talks, Calls for Iran's 'White Flag of Surrender' (Video)

Exposed: 1,000 Fake Marriages, Tens of Millions in Fraud

Trump Administration Announces Historic Funding for Faith-Based Humanitarian Orgs, Samaritan's Purse, World Vision and More

US Missionary Freed from 9 Months in Captivity After White House Prioritized His Rescue

Trump Effect: Prescription Drug Prices Fall At Record-Breaking Pace

Dem Senate Nominee and Muslim El-Sayed in the Hot Seat after 'Sickening' Animal Control Record Goes Viral on Social Media

A 7-Year-Old Boy's Preventable Death Demands an End to Polite Silence

Mom Sues School that Retaliated Against Her for Objecting When It Subjected Her Kids to Trans/Intersex Propaganda

WNBA Embarrasses Itself with Absurd Embrace of Everything It Isn't

Hospitals 'Got Rich' and Were 'Mutilating' Children; Vance, HHS Officials Announce Report

Dutch Sheets, Lou Engle Rally Believers for Breakthrough in Iran: 'Pivotal Moment in History'

Podcaster Robby Starbuck Gets a Win against Google AI Chatbot's Horrendous Defamation, and Gives Us All a Warning

Miracle as Mother Trapped for 36 Hours Underneath Rubble from Colombia Earthquake Is Pulled Out Alive

Extreme Irony: Ex-Southern Poverty Law Center CFO Charged In Brazen Scheme to Secretly Pay $1.2M to White Supremacist Groups

Secret Service Switched Trump's Plane Over Iranian Threat

Karoline Leavitt Raised the Bar for All White House Press Secretaries to Come