The ruling partly upheld a lower court decision by Judge William Pauley, who called the law "particularly offensive to free speech principles," and struck it down in its entirety.

But in a 2-1 decision, the 2nd Circuit appeals panel reinstated one provision of the law requiring CPCs to disclose whether they have a licensed medical provider on staff who performs or directly supervises all services offered at the facility.

That portion of the ruling met with dissent from Judge Richard Wesley, who said the law's wording was vague enough to give "unbridled discretion" to city officials to determine which facilities must adhere to the requirements. The provision could see CPCs targeted for harassment or even closure by city officials who have made no secret of the fact that they want to shut them down, calling them 'sham clinics' for their refusal to offer abortion and, in some cases, contraception.

"Local Law 17 is a bureaucrat's dream," Judge Wesley wrote: "It contains a deliberately ambiguous set of standards guiding its application, thereby providing a blank check to New York City officials to harass or threaten legitimate activity." Wesley also said the city "does not have a right to sweep all those who, for faith-based reasons, think that abortion is not the right choice in with those who would defraud or intentionally mislead women making this important and personal decision."

The split decision was met with mixed feelings by CPC owners and their attorneys. They praised the appeals panel for the parts of the law they did strike down but also expressed concerns that the reinstated provision's wording may cause major problems for CPCs, which—unlike abortion clinics—are generally funded by donations, staffed by volunteers, and offer expensive services to women free of charge.

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

Campus Awakening Continues: Baptisms in Pickup Trucks, Physical Healings Reported in UniteUS College Revival at Pitt

Explosive Intel Report: Ukraine War Aid May Have Been Funneled to Biden Campaign, DNC

Indicted Democrat Rep. Found Guilty of More Than 2 Dozen Ethics Violations; Faces Possible Expulsion from Congress

Congress Requests Documents after Reports on California Hospice Fraud

Whistleblower Exposes Massive Election Fraud Ring in California; Claims Even Gangs Are Involved to Rig Petitions with Paid Homeless Signers [Video]

Ohio House Passes Indecent Exposure Modernization Act to Protect Children and Preserve Privacy, Despite Dem Opposition

WATCH Rubio Mic Drop: Epic Fury Is a Favor for the World. 'Step Up and Deal With It'

BEST OF THE BEST: ICE Officer Saves One-Year-Old Child's Life at JFK Airport

Senate Funds DHS without ICE or Border Patrol; Bill Now Heads to the House

'We Must Prepare for the Battle Ahead': Canada's House of Commons Passes Bill that Would Criminalize Quoting the Bible

Appeals Court Hands Trump Big Win on Detaining Illegal Immigrants

Transgender Illegal Alien Child-Rapist Gets 'Time Served' Sentence in Sanctuary NYC

International Olympic Committee Adopts New Policy on Transgender Identity and Women's Sports

Christian Photographer Who Refused Working Same-Sex Weddings Wins $800K Settlement With Louisville, KY

Highlighting 'Divine Calling': Pete Hegseth Pushes New Chaplain Insignia Policy

Iconic Actor John Cleese Warns against Islamic Takeover in Britain

Finland's Supreme Court Convicts Christian Politician of Crime for Biblical Views on Marriage

WATCH – ICE Agents Pass Out Water to Grateful Travelers: 'They're Here Doing a Job'

No, Texans and Floridians Do NOT Pay Twice the Taxes Paid by Californians

The Tide Is Turning on Transgender Ideology, but Democrats Haven't Caught Up