The ruling partly upheld a lower court decision by Judge William Pauley, who called the law "particularly offensive to free speech principles," and struck it down in its entirety.

But in a 2-1 decision, the 2nd Circuit appeals panel reinstated one provision of the law requiring CPCs to disclose whether they have a licensed medical provider on staff who performs or directly supervises all services offered at the facility.

That portion of the ruling met with dissent from Judge Richard Wesley, who said the law's wording was vague enough to give "unbridled discretion" to city officials to determine which facilities must adhere to the requirements. The provision could see CPCs targeted for harassment or even closure by city officials who have made no secret of the fact that they want to shut them down, calling them 'sham clinics' for their refusal to offer abortion and, in some cases, contraception.

"Local Law 17 is a bureaucrat's dream," Judge Wesley wrote: "It contains a deliberately ambiguous set of standards guiding its application, thereby providing a blank check to New York City officials to harass or threaten legitimate activity." Wesley also said the city "does not have a right to sweep all those who, for faith-based reasons, think that abortion is not the right choice in with those who would defraud or intentionally mislead women making this important and personal decision."

The split decision was met with mixed feelings by CPC owners and their attorneys. They praised the appeals panel for the parts of the law they did strike down but also expressed concerns that the reinstated provision's wording may cause major problems for CPCs, which—unlike abortion clinics—are generally funded by donations, staffed by volunteers, and offer expensive services to women free of charge.

To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE

PASS IT ON… Here Is How You Watch the Super Bowl 'All-American Halftime Show' Sponsored by TPUSA

After Impressive $1 Million Monday Box Office Haul, Amazon MGM Expanding 'Melania' into 200 More Theaters

Former Lesbian Goes from 'Borderline Satanism' to God Encounter: 'He'll Completely Transform Your Life'

'We're Under Attack': Jewish New Yorkers Blame Mayor Mamdani as Antisemitism Explodes

Illegal Alien Semi-Truck Driver Kills Amish Family in Head-On Crash; He Entered US Under Joe Biden

The President Unveils Drug Savings Website 'Trump Rx'

Trump Stops Tax Dollars from Funding Transgender Ideology in Other Countries

Planned Parenthood Drops Lawsuit Trying to Get Federal Funding Back from Trump

DOJ: Benghazi Attack Suspect Arrested, Will Face Charges in US; 'Time Will Not Stop Us from Going after These Predators'

A Cry from the Heart of the Nation: The 2026 National Gathering for Prayer and Repentance

Savannah Guthrie Pleads for Prayers, Kathie Lee Gifford Asks Believers to 'Bombard Heaven'

Muslims Target TX High Schools, Pass out Qurans, Hijabs

Elon Musk's Offices Raided amid Alleged Criminal Activity on Grok

Human Trafficking Crackdown Nets More than 600 Suspects, Rescues 170 Victims, Including 14 Children

Ryan Wesley Routh Sentenced to Life in Prison for Attempted Assassination of President Donald J. Trump and Assault of a Federal Law Enforcement Officer

Good News: Another Major Medical Group Denounces Trans Surgeries (Mutilation) for Children

President Trump's Huge Announcement at the National Prayer Breakfast

The Prince of Nigeria Grew Up: How to Spot and Protect Yourself from AI and Phishing Scams

Epstein Files Expose Links To Transgender Ideology's Wealthiest Backers

Praying for Trump's 'Quiet Hammer!'