The Republican-Controlled Senate Clock is Ticking; Should the President Consider Recess Appointments?
Zack Smith - Opinion : Nov 16, 2026
Daily Signal
All of this to say that there are good-faith arguments to be had about the precise details of how the president may exercise the recess-appointment power. But there's no question that the Constitution does give the president—any president—this power...
[DailySignal.com] On Jan. 3, 2027, a new Congress with Democrat majorities in both the House and Senate will officially gavel into session. (Screengrab image: via Fox News)
Until that happens, the current Republican-controlled Senate has pledged to stay in session to confirm President Donald Trump's outstanding judicial nominees and to reach a reconciliation package on the budget.
But time is short. Senate floor time is limited. And some Republican senators have already obstructed the confirmation of Trump's judicial picks in Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Texas.
There are also concerns that some senators may not attend all of the remaining Senate session—meaning crucial votes will be missed and may fail with no time to bring them up again.
To be clear, the Senate should stay in session and complete its work. But given these risks, some have discussed that Sen. John Thune, R-SD, should consider recessing the Senate once its work is done so that the president can fill the existing executive branch and judicial vacancies by recess appointments.
Almost every president in American history has made recess appointments with recent presidents such as Ronald Reagan making 240, Bill Clinton making 139, George W. Bush making 171, and Barack Obama making 32.
Moreover, presidents have appointed over 300 judges, including about a dozen Supreme Court justices through recess appointments.
What the Constitution Says
Article II, Section 2, Clause 3 of the Constitution says that "The President shall have Power to fill up all Vacancies that may happen during the Recess of the Senate, by granting Commissions which shall expire at the End of their next Session."
As the Congressional Research Service has made clear, a "recess appointee possesses the same legal authority as a Senate-confirmed appointee" but with a tenure that ends when the next Senate session ends. In this case, that would be in about a year.
But the Constitution doesn't directly answer the question of what break in Senate business qualifies as a recess. And under an innovation begun under Democratic Majority Leader Harry Reid, the Senate began holding pro forma sessions where about every three days a single senator gavels the Senate into session and then immediately gavels it out again to avoid triggering a formal recess in order to deprive presidents of the ability to make recess appointments.
This three-day timeframe matters because Article I, Section 5, Clause 4 provides that "Neither House, during the Session of Congress, shall, without the Consent of the other, adjourn for more than three days." If the House and the Senate cannot agree on when they should adjourn, Article II, Section 3 says that "in Case of Disagreement between them, with Respect to the Time of Adjournment, [the President] may adjourn them to such Time as he shall think proper."
A recess can be either an intra-session recess or an inter-session recess. Each Congress lasts for two years and is composed of two annual sessions. An intra-session recess occurs during a break in one of these sessions and an inter-session recess occurs between the sessions.
This distinction could matter.
In its 2014, 5-4 decision in National Labor Relations Board v. Noel Canning, written by then-Justice Stephen Breyer, the Supreme Court held that the president could make appointments during both intra-session and inter-session recesses. But it said that appointments couldn't be made for Senate breaks less than three days and that a "recess of more than 3 days but less than 10 days is presumptively too short to fall within the [Recess Appointments] Clause." But such appointments could be made in certain circumstances.
Justice Antonin Scalia, joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Clarence Thomas, and Justice Samuel Alito, took a different view that only inter-session recesses, "no matter how short," could trigger the president's ability to make recess appointments. (Of course, these justices also took the view that only vacancies that arose during the recess could be filled through the recess-appointment power.)
All of this to say that there are good-faith arguments to be had about the precise details of how the president may exercise the recess-appointment power. But there's no question that the Constitution does give the president—any president—this power.
From a constitutional perspective, any recess appointment the president might make would be on its strongest footing if made during an inter-session recess and if the Senate recess is longer than 10 days—or is at least longer than three days.
One other consideration the president might keep in mind is that Congress, in a judicially untested law, has tried to place a legislative limit on a president's ability to make recess appointments by purporting to restrict the ability of recess appointees to receive payment unless one of three conditions is met.
These include that the vacancy must have arisen within 30 days before the end of the Senate's session, a nomination had to be pending before the end of the session, or if a nomination was rejected within 30 days before the end of the session, a different individual received the recess appointment.
On top of that, Congress provided that if one of these exceptions allowing payment applies, the president must then submit a nomination for these positions to the next Senate session within 40 days. (A rejection of the nominee wouldn't terminate the recess appointment, and the recess appointee could continue serving until the end of the next session after the one during which they were appointed).
Because of blue slips—the Senate practice that if even a single home state senator objects to a federal district court nominee—states that have a Democratic senator face an uphill battle to get any federal district judge confirmed.
So, if the president wants to pursue this path. Here are the steps that should be followed:
Zack Smith is a senior legal fellow and manager of the Supreme Court and Appellate Advocacy Program in The Heritage Foundation's Institute for Constitutional Government.