To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE
Surprise Ruling: EU Court of Human Rights Upholds Italy's Ban on Embryo Research"The right to life is absolute, and this fundamental tenet makes it unnecessary to explain why a murderer, a disabled person, an abandoned child or an embryo should be kept alive. We do not need to evaluate their usefulness for society, but we remain hopeful regarding their potential. The embryo's right to life cannot be called into question by the fact that, until implantation, its potential for development is something that can be maintained artificially, because any such new technology is a natural development created by human beings." –Judge Dedov (European Union)—The Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights recently affirmed Italy's right to protect human embryos as it sees fit, in a ruling that rejected an Italian woman's request that she be allowed to donate her cryogenically frozen embryos to scientific research. Adelina Parrillo was challenging a law passed in Italy in 2004 that prohibits research on human embryos, on the grounds that the law is "incompatible with her right to respect for her private life and her right to the peaceful enjoyment of her possessions," as guaranteed by the European Convention of Human Rights. (Photo: Building of the European Court of Human Rights/Shutterstock/via LifeSiteNews) In other words, Parrillo was asking the Court to recognize that human embryos are objects, "possessions" whose owners may use them as they see fit. Adelina Parrillo, now in her early sixties, obtained the embryos through in vitro fertilization in 2002 together with her husband, a filmmaker who died in tragic circumstances during a bomb attack in Iraq in late 2003. At that time the embryos had not yet been implanted, and the widow decided not to go ahead with the medically assisted reproduction procedure. The frozen embryos were kept in the Rome fertility clinic where the in vitro fertilization took place and are still in storage there, in what Jérôme Lejeune, the great French pro-life geneticist, once called the "Concentration can" when witnessing in favor of the life of other frozen embryos in Maryland, Tennessee, back in 1989. (Photo: Embryonic stem-cell/via SBA-list.org) But contrary to the Maryland case that involved a woman who wanted to obtain custody of her and her ex-husband's frozen embryos in order to give them a chance to live through implantation, Adelina Parrillo, who is now in her sixties, wanted her embryos offered up to a "noble cause," as she calls it: embryonic stem cell research. After a number of oral requests she formally presented a written demand, explaining that donating the five embryos would "be a source of comfort to her after the painful events that had occurred in her life," rather than destroying them or letting them die. The clinic's director refused: since 2004, using embryos for research is considered a punishable offence in Italy. Parrillo immediately turned to the European Court of Human Rights, arguing that any action before the ordinary courts in Italy was bound to fail because of the "blanket ban" on donating embryos to scientific research. The Court agreed that she would probably have found no "effective remedy" in the Italian judiciary system and agreed to examine the affair. It also agreed that Parrillo rightly invoked article 8 of the European Convention of Human Rights because "the applicant's ability to exercise a conscious and considered choice regarding the fate of her embryos concerns an intimate aspect of her personal life and accordingly relates to her right to self-determination." And not her "family life" which is also protected under article 8: Parrillo was most emphatically not pleading for her embryos to be implanted—a course which is not in any case open to widows under law 40/2004. Click here to read more.
To receive daily emails from Breaking Christian News to your inbox CLICK HERE Other Recent Articles from Breaking Christian News Elon Musk to Pay Embattled Doctor's Legal Fees after Speaking Out against COVID Lockdowns Safety of Women Hangs in Balance after Oral Arguments on Abortion Pill Regulation New Federal Gun Grab Law Would Criminalize Shooting Ranges, and Even Private Security Treasury Sec. Yellen: Biden Has NO Plan to Save Social Security Chick-fil-A Abandons Long-Held 'No Antibiotics' Pledge on Chicken The War in Myanmar: Karenni Resistance Fighters Ask for Prayer and Practical Help The World Is Facing a Major Population Crisis by 2075 If Birth Rates Keep Falling FDA Admits COVID Vaccines Cause Seizures in Toddlers Kamala Harris Won't Disclose Why Biden Campaign Is Active on TikTok Despite Security Worries 'Unthinkable Tragedy': Baltimore Bridge Collapses after Being Struck by Cargo Ship Jews, Christians Celebrate Purim, Palm Sunday as Israel Fights for Victory over Hamas Married People More Likely to Be 'Thriving': Gallup Survey Planet Fitness Is Having a 'Bud Light' Moment The Shocking Untold History of the Man Who Designed the 'Transgender Flag' Moscow Concert Massacre: US Border Chief Very Concerned a Similar Attack Could Happen Here Search the Articles Archives |
All articles on this site and emails from BCN are copyrighted property of Breaking Christian News. Permission is given to link to, or share a BCN story if proper attribution is given to both the original writer and summarizer of the story. Breaking Christian News 2005-2019. All Rights Reserved.
Breaking Christian News is a division of Elijah List Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved
Disclaimer: Articles and links, as well as the source articles linked to; do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Breaking Christian News.
Home | Store | Subscribe | Facebook | Article Archive |